Compare Two IVF Treatment Plans: A Side-by-Side Method That Actually Works
Two IVF quotes are rarely two prices for the same thing. This method lines up the medical plans first, then prices what happens if the cycle does not go to script.
Two quotes are two opinions about your case
When two clinics send you numbers, it is tempting to put the totals next to each other and pick the lower one. Usually that does not work, because the two quotes describe different treatments. One may assume conventional IVF and a fresh transfer. The other may include ICSI, embryo testing and a freeze-all cycle with a frozen transfer on a second trip. Those are two different plans for your care, not two prices for one.
The method below compares the plans first and the prices second. It assumes you already have two written quotes. To check whether each quote is complete on its own, use our IVF quote checklist for Medellín first.
Step 1: write each plan as one sentence
Before touching the numbers, rewrite each clinic’s proposal in a single plain sentence covering the same elements. For example: “Antagonist stimulation, retrieval, ICSI, culture to day 5, PGT-A on all blastocysts, freeze-all, one frozen transfer on a second trip.”
Use the same order every time: stimulation approach, fertilisation method, how long embryos are cultured, any testing, fresh or frozen transfer, number of embryos to transfer, and number of trips. If you cannot fill in an element, that is your first question for the clinic.
Step 2: list the medical differences and ask why
Put the two sentences side by side and underline every difference. For each one, ask both clinics, in writing, why they chose their approach for you and what they think of the alternative. Common differences include:
- ICSI or conventional IVF. Is ICSI recommended because of a sperm or fertilisation problem, or is it the clinic’s routine? See our guide to ICSI in a Medellín quote.
- Embryo testing. The UK regulator’s add-on rating for PGT-A (HFEA, 2023) is red for improving the chance of a baby for most fertility patients. If one plan includes it, ask what specific reason applies to you.
- Number of embryos to transfer. The ASRM/SART guidance on transfer limits (2021) strongly encourages single-embryo transfer for patients under 35 with a favourable prognosis. A plan that transfers two embryos is not better value. It carries a higher risk of a twin pregnancy.
- Fresh transfer or freeze-all. Is freezing everything a precaution for your situation, a requirement of embryo testing, or the clinic’s standard practice?
If the reasons leave you with two genuinely different medical opinions, stop the price comparison there. That is when a second clinical opinion is worth having.
Step 3: price each plan under three scenarios
A quote usually prices the cycle going to plan. Your real cost depends on what happens when it does not. Ask each clinic what you would pay in three scenarios:
- Smooth cycle: stimulation, retrieval and transfer go to plan.
- Change of course: transfer is postponed and embryos are frozen, so a frozen transfer is needed on a second trip.
- Early stop: the cycle is cancelled before retrieval, or no embryo is suitable for transfer.
Lay the answers out like this. The entries below are illustrative only and show the kind of differences to look for, not real prices:
| Scenario | Plan A (illustrative) | Plan B (illustrative) |
|---|---|---|
| Smooth cycle | Lower headline price; medications extra | Higher headline price; medications included |
| Change of course | Freezing, storage and frozen transfer each charged separately | Freezing and first year of storage included; frozen transfer extra |
| Early stop | Partial refund of unused steps, terms in the contract | No refund; credit towards a new cycle |
| Trips needed | One, or two if the course changes | Always two, because freeze-all is planned |
Seen this way, the “cheaper” plan may or may not stay cheaper. What matters is which scenarios are realistic for you, and only your doctors can tell you that.
Step 4: compare what you are actually buying
An IVF cycle is a route to one or more chances at transfer, not a product in itself. For each plan, ask how many embryos the clinic expects for someone with your profile, and how many transfer attempts the price covers. A plan that includes a frozen transfer may cover more chances than one that prices only a fresh transfer.
Be careful with success figures. The HFEA’s advice on treatment abroad warns that rates can be presented in misleading ways, for example by covering only women under 35 or by counting pregnancies rather than births. If two clinics quote rates that measure different things, you cannot compare them. Our guide to comparing IVF success rates explains what to ask for.
Step 5: add the travel and time budget separately
Keep the trip outside the medical comparison so that bundled extras do not hide a difference. For each plan, count the trips, the nights per trip, whether a partner must travel, and the cost of flexible fares. A plan that always needs two trips may cost more overall even if its medical price is lower, or it may suit you better because each trip is shorter.
Step 6: weigh the things a price cannot show
When the numbers are close, other differences decide. Ask both clinics the same questions:
- Who is my treating doctor, and will I see them at each step?
- How quickly do you reply, and in what language?
- Will I get my records, embryology report and a treatment summary before I leave? The CDC Yellow Book (2026) advises medical travellers to get their records in English and to ask about follow-up costs.
- How are complaints handled? The HFEA recommends finding this out in advance and getting legal advice on whether a contract with an overseas clinic could be enforced.
Traps that distort a side-by-side comparison
- Different currencies. One clinic may quote in U.S. dollars and another in Colombian pesos. Convert both at the same rate on the same day, and ask which currency you will actually be charged in, because exchange-rate movements between quote and payment can change the comparison.
- Different expiry dates. Ask how long each quote is valid. A lower price that expires before your likely start date is not really the lower price.
- Different deposit terms. Compare how much is due up front, when, and what is refundable if your plans change before treatment starts.
- Different assumptions about you. One clinic may have priced on the basis of your records and the other on a general package. Ask each one what assumptions about your age, tests and expected response sit behind the number.
- Bundled travel. If one quote includes lodging or transfers and the other does not, take those out before you compare the medical totals.
Putting it together
At the end you should have one page per clinic: the plan sentence, the medical differences with each clinic’s reasons, the three-scenario prices, the number of transfer chances, the travel budget and the softer factors. Lay the two pages side by side. They will not tell you which treatment is right. That needs a doctor who knows your case. They will show you exactly where the real differences are and which questions are still open.
Questions worth sending the clinic
- Please confirm my plan in one sentence: stimulation, fertilisation, culture, testing, transfer and trips.
- Why did you choose this approach for me instead of the alternatives?
- What would I pay if my transfer is postponed and embryos are frozen?
- What would I pay, or get back, if the cycle stops before retrieval or transfer?
- How many transfer attempts does this price cover?
- What does any success figure you have quoted actually count?
Frequently asked questions
What if the two clinics recommend completely different treatments?
Then you are not comparing prices yet. Ask each doctor to explain in writing why they chose their approach and what they think of the other one. If the gap stays large, a third opinion from a fertility specialist who has reviewed your records may be worth more than any saving.
Is the cheaper IVF plan usually missing something?
Not always, but check. The HFEA warns that low IVF prices may leave out drugs, blood tests or consultations. Price both plans under the same scenarios before concluding that one is cheaper.
Should I choose the plan with the higher success rate?
Only if you know what each rate counts and who it describes. The HFEA notes that rates can cover only younger patients or count pregnancies rather than births. Two figures measured differently cannot be compared.
Does a plan with PGT-A give me better chances?
Not for most patients, according to current evidence. The HFEA rates PGT-A red for improving the chance of a baby for most fertility patients. Ask the clinic why it recommends PGT-A in your case and what the plan would cost without it.
How do I compare a package price with an itemised quote?
Break the package back into the same steps as the itemised quote, and ask the package clinic what is excluded and what happens financially if the cycle ends early. Then price both under the same three scenarios.
Request Medellín fertility provider matches.
Tell us what you are comparing, your timing and your travel plans. If you authorize it, we may share your request with up to three participating providers. Keep medical records and detailed health history out of the marketing form.
Commercial lead scoring reflects readiness only. It does not measure fertility, prognosis or treatment eligibility.
Sources & verification
- HFEA: Fertility treatment abroad
- HFEA: PGT-A add-on rating (2023)
- ASRM/SART: Guidance on the limits to the number of embryos to transfer (2021)
- CDC Yellow Book 2026: Medical tourism
Cross-border treatment rules, clinic policies and evidence reviews can change. Re-check primary sources and the clinic's current written policy before making a decision.